Date archives "July 2006"

Rosa Zubaretta on “lay peer-to-peer networks” vs. “conventional group facilitation.”

In my own vision of peer to peer, this new relational dynamic is not a panacea for all human problems, and the last thing we want is a kind of totalitarian Commons-type of society. P2P is appropriate in some circumstances, will influence other modes, and will often exist in hybrid combinations. In our new topical… Continue reading

Open Business Guide Launched

[bliki|what is a bliki?] If you are not already familiar with Open Business.cc, it’s an open knowledge commons worth looking at and participating in. The basic core concepts of Open Business can be found under the idea section: “Open business is designed to help the little guy along on his journey to spread his idea… Continue reading

A preliminary conclusion on the debate on democracy and peer governance

After the various discussions with Marc and Sam, I have shifted my opinion and am more critical of the original text by Marc Fawzi. To summarize: I agree that in some cases, crowd-only systems may lead to average or lowest-common-denominator judgments, and that in these cases, they might be usefully augmented by a mixed crowd-hierarchy… Continue reading

Steve Harnad on the difference between open access to code, to text, and to data

Steven Harnad, an open access publishing expert, gets worked up about the conflation of the meaning of open and free, as used in software, with open and free as used in text, and then again, in data. These distinctions are valid, and no doubt important in certain applications of his field. But I would still… Continue reading

Richard Poynder continues his excellent open access interviews

Richard Poynder has patiently been working on conducting a series a lengthy and highly qualitative online interviews: the Basement Interviews. The last series of 3 are essentially concerned with the founders of open access publishing initiatives, and I have indexed them here. They concern Harold Varmus, Nobel Laureate and co-founder of the Public Library of… Continue reading

Why Digg Is A Poor Example Of “The Wisdom of Crowds”

[originally posted at Social Synergy Weblog] In this post, I want to address Marc Fawzi’s “Unwisdom of Crowds” post, as part of an analysis/debate that was initiated by Michel Bauwens of the P2P blog. First, Marc lays out his case to compare certain behaviors online to human “tribal” behavior (as in hunter/gatherer societies). The following… Continue reading

Web 2.0. and the increase in software productivity

Michael Schrage has an interesting article claiming that recent productivity gains might make outsourcing obsolete. Of particular interest is this quote showing the productivity gain in producing software after the open source revolution: “So when Brondmo told me his software, called Plum, was the first time he’d done serious coding in over a decade, I… Continue reading

What drives online cooperation: agonistic giving

Trebor Scholz has a great post investigating the motivations behind social networking and other forms of social collaboration. It’s a contribution related to both Jaron Lanier’s rant against digital maoism, and our own dialogue with Marc Fawzi on the unwisdom of crowds. It basically asks: is the motivation selfish, or altruistic. Note that this very… Continue reading