P2P Foundation

Researching, documenting and promoting peer to peer practices


Featured Book

Misunderstanding the Internet


Open Calls


Mailing List

Subscribe

Translate

  • Recent Comments:

    • Øyvind Holmstad: “In this regard it attains the radical democratic ideal of unanimous consent of the governed, which is never completely...

    • Øyvind Holmstad: No, the commons cannot work through more free time, the commons can only occur through pattern languages maintaining the human...

    • Steve Herrick: The link should be: this.

    • Carlos Boyle: Muro Walf says, about Elisabeth Noelle Neumann’s the Spiral of Silence, that people prioresses “where to position them selves ”...

    • Øyvind Holmstad: Have you heard about the “universal scaling law” by Nikos Salingaros: http://meandering-through-m...

Alf Hornborg: We need an economy with two incommensurable currencies

photo of Michel Bauwens

Michel Bauwens
1st October 2011


What we need is an economy with at least two incommensurable currencies, to distinguish between values that should not be interchangeable, such as local subsistence and survival versus globalized entertainment

Excerpted from an interview with Alf Hornborg:

Q: “Following David Harvey’s analysis of money, you have suggested that money is a social institution that generates “space-time” in such a way that is both an “objective, political ecological framework” and a “subjective experience.” In other words, money becomes the medium by which society, technology and even the whole biosphere are transformed within a particular set of cultural ideas. Given the latest financial crises, what do you foresee the role of currency to be in the transformation of the relationship between ecology and economics?

The financial crises illustrate the risks a society takes when it permits monetary assets and real, biophysical resources to become so thoroughly dissociated from each other. Our current problems with overconsumption would not have been possible if money had not become so completely disconnected from material resources. I am not saying that the gold standard that we abandoned in the seventies was a solution, but at least it limited the possibilities of printing ever more money to keep the treadmill of consumption (and production) spinning at a pace that satisfies the corporate demand for profits. But the real problem with money is not that it is fictitious, as all money must be, but that it embodies the idea that everything can be exchanged for everything else. What we need is an economy with at least two incommensurable currencies, to distinguish between values that should not be interchangeable, such as local subsistence and survival versus globalized entertainment.”

Share

One Response to “Alf Hornborg: We need an economy with two incommensurable currencies”

  1. Mike Riddell Says:

    I would argue that the secondary currency should be community based so that it has a built in local bias, and which is only ever issued to people who ‘contribute’ to that community. Teaching, giving or learning could all be classified as contribution. Inflation would only ever occur when too much contribution was being made so would that ever be an issue?

    Better to measure success by reference to contribution that by reference to GDP.

    @mikeriddell62

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>